Phase 3: Interpreting Information

Updated 1 year 3 months ago

In this Phase, I will be building my knowledge on the Flying Tigers in order to aid my research in Xizhou. This will be working document with information being added until my inquiry project is 100% complete. I will be gathering information through, interviews, books, and online sources. I have made the decision to research the Flying Tigers during my time in Xizhou in Phase 1 and laid out the big questions that will guide my investigation for my inquiry project. 

Background Information (from Phase 1): 

General Claire Lee Chennault was a retired U.S. Army Air Corps Captain and accepted an offer from Soong Mei-ling to conduct a confidential evaluation of the Chinese Air Force.[2] He received aid from Western nations because he was fighting the communists. However, Claire Lee Chennault's birthdate is not known and there is no proof of a man named Claire Lee Chennault born on September 6, 1893, in Commerce, Texas. In fact, Chennault himself claims that he is born in 1890.[1] He was the leader of an aerobatics team called the Three Men on a Flying Trapeze.[1,2] Because he was a phenomenal performance in the air, he was asked to fly fighters competing to be the Army Air Corps' new generation of fighter planes, the Curtiss-Wright P-36, and the Seversky P-35.[1] Gen. Chennault went from being a teacher in a one-room schoolhouse in Athens, Georgia to being the leader of the famed Flying Tigers. The Japanese and the Chinese were at the brink of an all-out war and was still relatively unready with biplanes that could be easily outperformed by advanced Japanese monoplanes.[2] The public is kept in the dark about Chennault's position and role in the Chinese Air Force, and he maintains that he is simply a civilian advisor. [1,2] He was to create a new Chinese Air Force after the American counterpart. He expertly and strategically positioned airfields and also created a sophisticated and failsafe air raid warning system with Jing Bao to protect China's civilians from Japan's terror bombing campaign.[2] 

The Chinese were interested in purchasing a low-cost, export version of the P-36 fighter and sent a representative the Air Force along with the representative of Curtiss-Wright in China, William Pawley.[1] His revolutionary opinions about aerial combat were not greeted with enthusiasm in the Army Air Force. He stepped on one too many toes in the military, ending his career in the air.[1,4] Because China has always been a major client of Curtiss-Wright. Because of the Fall of France, the products of a production line dedicated for the French was to be sent to the Britain for the Royal Air Force. The vice-president of Curtiss-Wright, Burdette Wright, came up with a proposal for  British, if they were to waive their 100 priority P-40B's, they will be provided with 100 later-model P-40's more suitable for combat. This proposition was accepted by the British, as they will be provided with 100 planes that are more advanced. The Flying Tigers also benefited and received their first 100 planes.[2]

The name Flying Tiger was given by the grateful Chinese population after it routed Japanese bombers near Kunming on December 20, 1941. The local newspaper dubbed the group, "Fei Hu," or Flying Tigers.[2,4,5] The pilots were paid $600 per month and a bonus $500 per Japanese plane shot down.[1] This was enticing as the pay was much higher than an average U.S. airman serving with the Marine Corps, Army Air Corps, or Navy.[1] Also, many Americans wanted to fight the Japanese but couldn't do so in the American military as the United States was still neutral. The Flying Tigers were to protect China's lifeline, the Burma Road, from Japanese attacks.[1,2] Japanese attacks and invasions have forced the government to retreat into its Western plateaus. Manchuria was invaded in 1931 and the China proper in 1937.[1,3] The only port of supply for China is only Rangoon in the British colony of Burma. As Japan has made attempts to capture Burma, it threatened to sever China's lifeline completely. 

The tension was mounting in the region after the annexation of Manchuria and Korea.[6] The tension rose further with the Marco Polo Bridge incident. During the incident, Japanese and Chinese forces exchanged fire as the Japanese forces tried to take the Marco Polo Bridge for a tactical advantage.[6] The Japanese sent a message to the Chinese demanding the right to search the city after Private Shimura Kikujiro of the Japanese military failed to return to his post. The Chinese held the bridge amid the waves of Japanese onslaught and a truce was negotiated. 

The area of Southern China and Yunnan has played an important role in the history of the Flying Tigers. It was the site of the first Flying Tigers attack on the Japanese Air Force, kickstarting their legacy and boosting Chinese morale. Southern China also marks one end of the Burma Road, a crucial supply line the Flying Tigers protected to keep China in the war. 

Information from local contacts:

03/08/17 Mr. Yun:

Mr. Yun works in the Linden Centre, he knows where the Flying Tigers sites are. This is a secondary source and this information needs to be verified with a primary source. 

  • The Flying Tigers radar station is at Jishanyi.

03/09/17 Mrs. Zhao:

Mrs. Zhao was 8 or 9 years old when the Flying Tigers arrived in Xizhou. She shared some memories of the Flying Tigers era.

  • The Flying Tigers were kind, gave her needles and yarn for knitting, as well as medicine.
  • They were very good-looking young men.
  • Planes circled overhead everyday, several times per day.
  • She was scared when the Flying Tigers first arrived but became closer after daily interactions.
  • She also remembers talking to Gen. Chennault through an interpreter.
  • The Flying Tigers were welcomed in the community because of their kindness.
  • After the Flying Tigers headed for home, they left for good.
  • She regards the Flying Tigers as "the very best".
  • An obelisk near the house commemorating the Flying Tigers is not in good conditions.

03/13/17 Mr. Linden:

Mr. Linden has been in China for about 10 years. He is the founder of all Linden complexes. 

  • He has a book the Flying Tigers used to learn daily and military Chinese phrases, as well as rank insignias of the Chinese Army and identification of Japanese aircraft.
  • Preserving history is hard because of the political climate.
  • The Flying Tigers history does not favor the Communists.
  • Flying Tigers worked with the Kuomintang, which persecuted the Communists.
  • Some part of this history should and deserve to be preserved.
  • Preserving history in China can have many nuances.
  • There are not many contacts that are in Xizhou left
  • Not everyone is willing to talk
  • He heard from elders that the Flying Tiger members gave candy to kids

03/14/17 Mr. Zhao Shi Long:

Mr. Zhao lives on the former Flying Tigers radar site. He remembers the Flying Tigers staying in his house from 1942-1945.

  • The Flying Tigers gave him a lot of fruit candy
  • American cargo planes flying over "The Hump" will circle his house to gain altitude several times a day
  • He lived on the first floor while the Flying Tigers operated the radar mounted on the roof on the second floor of the house
  • The children of the Flying Tigers often came back to visit him
  • Not everyone knew why they were here
  • Mr. Zhao believes they were here to protect China and repel the Japanese
  • He believes they helped the China a great deal and China should be grateful
  • Mr. Zhao says he would only allow the government to transform his house into a museum if it is a beneficial move

03/15/17 Mr. Su:

Mr. Su is an antique shop owner born in the 70's. 

  • He reads about the Flying Tigers on novels
  • His parents did not tell him much about the Flying Tigers
  • There are some youths that do not think the Flying Tigers were real
  • The Flying Tigers played a big part in the history and it is definitely real
  • China should be thankful to the U.S. for the assistance in defeating Japan
  • A country will be a failure if it cannot preserve their culture
  • Mr. Su believes no one can rewrite history, even if it is 1,000 years later.

03/15/17 Mr. Yang:

Mr. Yang sells Xizhou baba at Sifangjie. Because he is an older member of his family, he somewhat remembers the Flying Tigers.

  • He barely remembers the Flying Tigers because he was 4 at the time
  • He recommends talking to people that are 80 or older

03/16/17 Mrs. Dong:

Mrs. Dong works in the Golden Flower restaurant. 

  • She does not remember the Flying Tigers and her parents did not tell her much
  • There is an obelisk at the Flying Tigers site

03/16/17 Mr. Yan:

Mr. Yan sells Xizhou baba at Sifangjie. 

  • He does not hear much about the Flying Tigers
  • His parents told him about how people from JiShanYi rescued a pilot of the Flying Tigers after the plane was downed

03/20/17 Mr. Yang:

Mr. Yang is a close friend of an antique shop owner also named Mr. Yang. He gave me some information about his views on the Flying Tigers.

  • He knew about the Flying Tigers because his parents told him about it, he had an uncle that was killed in a Japanese bombing
  • A North American B-25 Mitchell medium bomber crashed in Mt. Gong in the 1940's and was recovered in the 1990's. 
  • A former member of the Flying Tigers visited Tengchong, where the wreckage of the bomber was displayed.
  • JiShanYi is a radar station to guide the planes over the Hump. 
  • It was important because the Himalayans were very tall, windy and foggy, making it dangerous for aviation.
  • The Japanese planes often bombed Wuchiaba airport in Kunming.
  • Another major target frequently visited by Japanese bombers is Chengbei Airport.
  • They made a giant contribution in helping China defend against the Japanese.
  • It is a piece of history worth preserving.

03/20-21/17 Mr. Kang:

Mr. Kang works at Old Town Snacks and is a history enthusiast.

  • He learned of the Flying Tigers by reading history books.
  • He started becoming interested in the Flying Tigers when he discovered them in middle school.
  • There were many Flying Tigers personnel and planes stationed in Yunnan-yi.
  • His parents did not know about the Flying Tigers because they are not from Xizhou.
  • The brave acts of the Flying Tigers should be taught in schools to students.
  • He tells his own children about the Flying Tigers.
  • He believes this part of history should be kept alive because the Flying Tigers helped China defeat Japan.

Answers to Questions From Phase 1:

1. Why were the Flying Tigers deployed in the Southern China, more specifically Xizhou?

Because Kunming was a very populated city and an economic and industrial center, as well as the end of the Burma Road, or China's lifeline, it was subject to terror bombing campaigns by the Japanese. Because the Chinese Air Force had been decimated, the Japanese gained near-absolute air superiority, meaning they can bomb civilians unchallenged in the air by modern fighters. The Flying Tigers, equipped with one of the most advanced, well-armed and durable fighters of the era, definitely changed that. Becuase the Japan has seized Burma, and because of the natural barrier of the Himalayas, a considerable amount of resources had to be flown over the mountains. This was an extremely dangerous method of transportation and Xizhou is a radar station that helped guide the planes flying in and out of the Chinese airspace. 
 
What Became of This Question: I used this question and received answers identical to my answer.
 
2. What made the Flying Tigers significant, especially in Xizhou?
They protected China and gained air superiority. The Flying Tigers ensured that China would have Burma Road as its lifeline. 
 
What Became of This Question: I did not use this question because it was merged with the first question.
 
3. How did the locals see them, were they welcomed?
From reading Microcampus projects from the past, the residents of Xizhou said the members of the famed Flying Tigers were courteous and kind. They were helpful to the residents. 
 
What Became of This Question: I used this sentence to see how the Flying Tigers interacted with the community and got the same response. 
 
4. How did the presence of the Flying Tigers affect the daily lives of the local residents?
From past project, especially with the case of Mr. Zhao, some had to yield their home to accommodate the Flying Tigers. The civilians in Xizhou most likely had to make some sacrifices and adjustments for the newcomers to their community. 
 
What Became of This Question: I did not use this question because it was merged with the top question.
 
5. What are some remarkable memories the people have about the Flying Tigers?
There were most likely good memories, giving people a ride on their jeeps, etc. 
 
What Became of This Question: I used this question and Mr. Zhao Shi Long told me that the Flying Tigers gave out candy, Mrs. Zhao told me they were given medicine by the Flying Tigers.
 
6. How did the residents assist the Flying Tigers?
They gave the Flying Tigers some of their living space to accommodate the group.
 
What Became of This Question: I used this question to see how the community, if at all, gave back to the Flying Tigers.
 
7. After the Flying Tigers left, how did the community change?
I am not very sure. This is something I hope to find out in Xizhou.
 
What Became of This Question: I felt like this question was irrelevant after I narrowed down my topic. 
 
8. Did the Flying Tigers leave behind anything with historical significance?
They did leave behind a radar station and it would definitely be reasonable to think there would be something from back then in the Linden Centre. 
 
What Became of This Question: They did leave behind the book and not too many other things. 
 
9. Was there anything controversial that the Flying Tigers did?
This, I really have no idea about. Perhaps some may think they did not make a big splash right then.
 
What Became of This Question: This question was answered through conversations about other questions.
 
10. What is something non-tangible that the Flying Tigers leave in Xizhou?
The Flying Tigers made Xizhou special by adding a special part to their history. I think it is the legacy they made in Xizhou that is significant.
 
What Became of This Question: I learned about all the memories the elders had through the previous questions, which rendered this question useless. 

If all goes according to plan, I will start Phase 4 tomorrow. Phase 4 will help me brainstorm and organize ideas for my final piece. 

Sources:

1. Ford, Daniel. Flying Tigers: Claire Chennault and the American Volunteer Group. Washington: Smithsonian Institution, 1991. Print.
2. "Brief History of the Flying Tigers." Flying Tigers Association. Web. 25 Jan. 2017.
3. "Sino-Japanese War." Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc., 02 Sept. 2009. Web. 25 Jan. 2017.
4. Dogfights: Flying Tigers. By Cynthia Harrison. Prod. Brooks Wachtel, Robert Kirk, Rob Lihani, Cynthia Harrison, and Jason McKinley. Dir. Robert Kirk. History Channel, 2006. Dogfights:Flying Tigers Season 1 Episode 3. EverythingAboutWWII, 25 Jan. 2014. Web. 27 Jan. 2017.
5. Regan, Ronald V. "American Volunteer Group: Claire L. Chennault and the Flying Tigers." HistoryNet. HistoryNet, 22 June 2016. Web. 27 Jan. 2017.
6. L., Orion. "Phase 3: Interpreting Information." Shanghai American School Microcampus. Orion L., 27 Jan. 2016. Web. 30 Jan. 2017.
7. Mr. Yun. Personal Interview conducted by Barton C., Mar 8. 2017.
8. Mrs. Zhao. Personal Interview conducted by Barton C., March 9. 2017.
9. Mr. Linden. Personal Interview conducted by Barton C., March 13. 2017.
10. Mr. Zhao. Personal Interview conducted by Barton C., March 14. 2017.
11. Mr. Su. Personal Interview conducted by Barton C., March 15. 2017.
12. Mr. Yang. Personal Interview conducted by Barton C., March 15. 2017.
14. Mrs. Dong. Personal Interview conducted by Barton C., March 16. 2017.
15. Mr. Yan. Personal Interview conducted by Barton C., March 16. 2017.
16. Mr. Yang. Personal Interview conducted by Barton C., March 20. 2017.
17. Mr. Kang. Personal Interview conducted by Barton C., March 20. 2017.
18. Mr. Kang. Personal Interview conducted by Barton C., March 20. 2017

Comments

你為你的項目努力,恭喜你一天天有進展

Barton

剛剛跟媽媽看了你的工作進展,你一條條紀錄了你採訪的人提供的資訊,

當你找到一個80多歲的人,這個人要當時跟飛虎隊有很多接觸,還要開啟她(他)塵封已久的記憶,這不是一件容易的事

這個過程一定遇到很多困難,願你可以一一克服困難,達成目標

祝願你一切順利平安

 

CC

 

 

Hi there! My name is Barton C. I had a great time in Xizhou during the Microcampus program. These are four weeks that made me look at my life and my work ethic differently. My four weeks as a Superior was one of my fondest memories of middle school. I am a baseball outfielder and pitcher, die-hard fan of the Detroit Tigers, as well as one of the few (only?) Microcampus alumni with a Private Pilot License. My project focused on the preservation of the Flying Tigers' history in Xizhou. If you are interested in a project regarding the Flying Tigers, building upon my project or aviation, you may reach me via my email at barton01px2021@saschina.org.